We Tried And Ranked 8 Of The Best Frozen Pizzas And The Winner Had Us Shook

Totino's Party Pizza

Expected more from this childhood favorite. With unmelted cheese and lackluster crust, it’s better suited for kids or those who don’t know better.

Whole Foods 365 Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza

Whole Foods excels in healthy food, but this pizza fell short. It’s greasy and lacks flavor, far from the chain’s usual standard.

Amy's 4 Cheese Pizza

A cheese pizza should shine with its cheese, but this one disappoints. As one taster said, “The cheese doesn’t deliver.”

Whole Foods 365 Thin Crust Supreme Pizza

Fresh toppings, but the flavor is lacking. It’s decent but nothing special. Whole Foods isn't known for pizza anyway.

Tombstone Original 5 Cheese Pizza

Cheese was tasty, but the overall pizza was mediocre. As noted, “The cheese was good, but the rest is meh.”

Newman's Own Thin & Crispy Uncured Pepperoni Pizza

Too thin to impress, with a crispy crust and lacking in sauce and toppings. Ideal if you prefer a super crispy base.

Amy's BBQ Pizza

This BBQ pizza is mostly on point. The tangy sauce shines despite a slightly chewy dough, making it a solid option.

DiGiorno Original Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza

Divisive among tasters, with mixed feelings about the pepperoni. It improves with time, making it enjoyable in the end.